Insurance For Everyone?

Daryl K. Rubin, Attorney • May 19, 2023

Insurance For Everyone?

You paid for health Insurance and auto Insurance. You’re prepared, right? Then, that fateful day comes when you’re driving down I-75 and a drunk driver merges into your lane. Suddenly, you find yourself waking up in the emergency room. While the emergency team examines your injuries, you’re glad you’re prepared.


Flash forward 30 days. What’s this? Your health insurance carrier is requesting to be repaid for bills that they’ve paid for your medical treatment. Your auto insurance is also demanding to be repaid. How can this be? You paid for the coverage; why should you have to pay them back?


It’s called subrogation, and virtually every auto- and health-insurance carrier in Ohio writes provisions such as these into policies. This provision requires that you, as their policy holder, repay them for the monies they have expended on your behalf when you decide to assert a claim against another person.


Here’s a summary of how it works: Your health insurer, as a condition to providing payment to a doctor, required the doctor to accept a schedule of “usual and customary” charges that the doctor has agreed, in advance, to accept for the medical services he would render. It makes no difference that the procedure normally billed by the doctor is, say, $200 per session. The insurance carrier will pay only $75 for the procedure, and the doctor has agreed with this payment schedule, agreeing further to write the balance off as a “cost of doing business.”


Why do doctors do this? If the doctor doesn’t cooperate with the health insurance company, those people that are insured with that particular insurance carrier will be required to seek medical services elsewhere. So, in the interest of preserving business, the doctor accepts a pay-cut. Your doctor now needs to see more people in an average working day, with shorter scheduled appointments, in order to receive enough money to pay overhead, meet payroll, and, hopefully, make a reasonable profit.  And remember, when the Health Insurer pays your doctor, they expect to be paid back by you in the event you get compensated by the Drunk Driver’s insurance carrier. So, exactly what did the Health Insurer pay? Interesting question!


What about your auto insurance coverage? You believe you have coverage that provides for payment of your medical bills. Did you wonder why your doctor wanted to submit his bill for medical services to your auto insurance company rather than your health insurance carrier? Your auto insurance carrier will pay 100% of the doctor’s bill without requiring the doctor to write-down his balance. Unfortunately, auto medical payment coverage is usually limited in amount. Typical coverage of $1,000, $2,000, or $5,000 is not uncommon. And, once the auto insurer has paid out the medical payment coverage, it’s gone. But, remember, you still need to pay them back if you make a recovery!  So, exactly what did the Auto Insurer pay? Interesting question! 


What about uninsured motorist coverage? If the other driver has a $25,000 policy, and assuming you collect this sum, your own uninsured motorist carrier would be entitled to reduce the amounts they have to pay you to compensate you for your injury. It works like this: The other driver has $25,000 in coverage. Your own policy provides for uninsured motorist coverage of $50,000. Therefore, your own insurance company will only have to pay you $25,000, not the $50,000 you obtained in coverage. And, from the original $25,000 you obtained from the other driver’s insurance company, you have to pay back your own subrogated carrier. Potentially, that first $25,000 of coverage could be substantially reduced, to even $0, for the monies you had to pay back.  And again, exactly what did the Auto Insurer pay? Another interesting question.


As you can see, your insurance premiums continue to go up, while artifice in the insurance industry has contrived mechanisms to pay you less.  Here’s another twist. As you worry about how your compensation is being nibbled away, you have to consider the difficulties you may encounter in establishing that the other party is solely negligent for the injuries you have sustained. Say, for instance, that the drunk driver tells his insurance company that he believes you were exceeding the speed limit. His insurance company will, in all likelihood, advise you that they are reducing the amount they feel obliged to pay by your own comparative negligence. Instead of paying 100% of your damages, they now propose to reduce this amount to, say, 75% based upon their own determination that your negligence should be assigned a 25% negligence factor.


We live in a complicated world, with complicated issues. Most of us trust others to give us fair insight into the decisions we need to make. It is unfortunate that something so simple should be the subject of such utter complication. 


Daryl K. Rubin is a General Partner in the Law Firm of Rubin-Zyndorf and Associates.

20 Feb, 2024
A Comprehensive Guide on Filing Workers' Compensation Claims in Ohio
20 Jan, 2024
Legal Assistance for Ohio Victims of Car Accidents Involving Rideshare Apps
16 Dec, 2023
Getting into a motorcycle accident can be a traumatic and overwhelming experience. From filing an insurance claim to seeking medical attention, the process can be complicated and tricky. It's crucial to know what to do after a motorcycle accident in Ohio to protect your legal rights and ensure you receive the compensation you deserve. In this post, we'll provide you with a step-by-step guide on what to do after a motorcycle accident.  1. Seek medical help The first and most important step after getting into a motorcycle accident is to seek medical attention. Even if you feel fine, adrenaline can mask injuries that may become evident later on. Even seemingly minor injuries can develop into larger problems, leading to chronic pain or disabilities. Therefore, it's essential to visit an emergency room or doctor as soon as possible to document your injuries and receive adequate treatment. 2. Document the accident After seeking medical help, the next step is to document the accident. Make sure to take photos of the accident scene, including the damaged vehicles and any other property damage. Photographs help provide evidence and establish fault in the case of a motorcycle accident. Collect information from any witnesses, including their contact information. Ask the police for a copy of the accident report. 3. Don't admit fault It's crucial not to admit fault when getting into a motorcycle accident. This is because under Ohio law, you can still collect compensation for your injuries even if you were partially at fault. Discussing the accident with other drivers or admitting fault could hurt your claim. Therefore, to protect your legal rights, avoid making statements that could make you appear at fault. 4. Contact a personal injury lawyer If you were injured in a motorcycle accident caused by the negligence of another driver, it's crucial to contact a personal injury lawyer experienced in motorcycle accidents. An experienced attorney can help you build a strong case to hold the at-fault party responsible for their actions and help you receive compensation for your damages. 5. File an insurance claim Finally, filing an insurance claim is essential to receive compensation for your injuries and property damage after a motorcycle accident. You must file the claim as soon as possible after the accident, even if you are unsure of how severe the damages are. Insurance companies have specific deadlines for filing claims, and failure to comply can jeopardize your chances of receiving fair compensation. In conclusion, knowing what to do after a motorcycle accident in Ohio is critical. Seeking medical attention, documenting the accident, not admitting fault, contacting a personal injury lawyer, and filing an insurance claim are all essential steps in protecting your legal rights and ensuring you receive the compensation you deserve. Remember, an experienced personal injury lawyer can help you navigate the legal process and maximize your chances of receiving fair compensation. Stay safe and be prepared.
03 Nov, 2023
Do You Sue the Truck Driver or Truck Company After a Crash?
30 Oct, 2023
Slip-and-fall accidents are unfortunate events that can happen to anyone at any time. These accidents can lead to injuries that range from minor to severe, and recovery can be a long and arduous process. If you have been the victim of a slip-and-fall accident, it is crucial to seek immediate medical attention and take action to protect your rights. In this comprehensive guide, we will outline the steps you should take immediately after a slip-and-fall accident to ensure you receive the care and compensation you deserve.  Step 1: Seek Medical Help The first step after experiencing a slip-and-fall accident is to seek medical attention. Even if you feel fine or have minor injuries, seeking medical attention is essential. Some injuries may not be immediately apparent, and delaying treatment can cause further complications. Seek medical attention from a healthcare provider or ER. After receiving the medical report, make sure you keep a copy of it. This medical report can be vital if you decide to pursue a lawsuit or settlement later on. Step 2: Collect Evidence After getting medical attention, it's vital to gather as much evidence about your slip-and-fall accident as possible. Take pictures of the location of the accident, including any hazards or obstacles that may have contributed to your fall. If there were witnesses, make note of their names and contact details. Collecting evidence can help establish liability and demonstrate negligence on the part of the property owner. Step 3: Fill Out an Accident Report Report the accident to the appropriate authority. Filing an accident report can help establish a paper trail and create a record of the incident. Report the accident to the property owner, manager, or security personnel onsite at the place of the accident. Most other locations like grocery stores, malls or apartments have an incident report form to fill out, get that form filled, and keep a copy of it for future reference. Step 4: Consult a Slip-and-Fall Attorney Navigating the world of slip-and-fall accidents and personal injury claims can be overwhelming. Having a legal representative, you can trust throughout the process is beneficial when you decide to pursue a lawsuit or settlement. Slip-and-fall attorneys have the experience and knowledge needed to assess your case and determine your legal options. They can help you gather and review evidence, establish liability and negotiate a settlement or represent you throughout the litigation phase. Step 5: Stay Patient and Diligent Personal injury claims can take a considerable amount of time to be resolved. It is essential to stay patient and diligent throughout the process, from filing your claim to negotiating a settlement or representing your case in court. Your slip-and-fall attorney will help guide you through each step and keep you informed of your rights and options as the case progresses. Slip-and-fall accidents can be painful, traumatic, and costly. However, with the help of an experienced slip-and-fall attorney and the right course of action, you can take to protect your rights and receive the compensation you deserve. Remember to seek medical attention immediately, collect evidence, report the incident, consult with an attorney, and stay patient and diligent throughout the process. These steps will give you a better chance of receiving compensation for your injuries and damages. If you're ever in a slip-and-fall accident, stay calm, and take the necessary steps to ensure you protect your rights and receive the care you need.
19 May, 2023
YOU SHOULD ALWAYS OBTAIN MEDICAL ATTENTION FOR INJURIES YOU SUFFERED IN AN ACCIDENT.
19 May, 2023
Call us if you’ve been injured in an accident. Why? Because we handle your claim honestly, professionally, and with the competence you deserve.
19 May, 2023
YOU SHOULD ALWAYS OBTAIN MEDICAL ATTENTION FOR INJURIES YOU SUFFERED IN AN ACCIDENT.
19 May, 2023
Whether you live in the Toledo area, or live Out of State, our office can help you maximize the financial compensation you are owed due to an injury.
Share by: